Let’s begin by stating the obvious: if you’ve ever dared to suggest that someone with Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) should “just cheer up,” you should probably duck. And then read a book. Or twelve.
People with BPD aren’t joyless because they’re allergic to puppies or because someone cursed their name with a rusty hex in 1998. No, it’s much more nuanced than that. Their emotional lives are basically a broken rollercoaster designed by someone on LSD — intense, unpredictable, and held together by duct tape and regret.
So the next time you roll your eyes at your BPD friend for being “too dramatic” or “never satisfied,” consider this your crash course in why joy is an elusive little bastard for people with BPD — and why you should sit down, shut up, and stop expecting Disney Channel outcomes from people who feel everything at 500% intensity.
1. Joy Isn’t a Switch — It’s a Friggin’ Mirage
People with BPD aren’t sitting around refusing joy like toddlers rejecting vegetables. It’s not a choice. It’s more like joy is a squirrel in a minefield — occasionally visible, always fleeting, and often blown to bits before it can be enjoyed.
You see, when your default internal setting is “emotional firestorm,” joy doesn’t exactly linger. It’s not that BPD folks can’t feel happiness — in fact, they might feel moments of joy more intensely than most people. The problem? That joy is immediately followed by crushing self-doubt, abandonment panic, or the suspicion that happiness is just a setup for disappointment.
Imagine getting a promotion at work and your first thought isn’t “Yay!” but “Oh God, what if they find out I’m a fraud and fire me tomorrow?” That’s not pessimism. That’s BPD.
2. Chronic Emptiness: Because Life Isn’t Fun When You Feel Like a Human Vacuum
One of the most fun little diagnostic features of BPD (note the sarcasm) is something called chronic emptiness. That’s psych speak for “feeling like an emotionally hollowed-out pumpkin year-round.”
Try finding joy when you feel disconnected from your own identity, relationships, and purpose. It’s like going to a party and realizing halfway through you have no idea why you’re there, who anyone is, or what your costume is supposed to be. (Spoiler: You’re the emotional wreck. That's the costume.)
People with BPD often feel like they’re watching their lives from the outside, as if everything is happening in a slightly wrong dimension. They may laugh, smile, and look like they're participating — but joy is about connection, and chronic emptiness is its emotional acid bath.
3. Fear of Abandonment: The Joy Killer You Didn’t Ask For
Nothing shuts down joy faster than the terror that the person you’re sharing it with is secretly packing their emotional bags.
People with BPD have a sixth sense for abandonment. Unfortunately, it’s not a reliable sense — it’s more like a haunted smoke detector that screams when someone blinks too slowly. It doesn’t matter if it’s real or imagined — the fear is consuming. The more joyful a moment, the more dangerous it feels. Why?
Because if something feels that good, losing it will hurt that much more.
This is why many people with BPD unconsciously sabotage good things. Not because they hate happiness, but because their internal radar is blaring “DANGER! TOO MUCH GOOD! IT’S ABOUT TO CRASH!” Joy becomes a liability, not a gift.
4. Splitting: Either It’s the Best Day Ever, or Everything Is Garbage
Ah yes, the BPD classic — splitting. This isn’t your average emotional swing. This is an extreme black-and-white thinking pattern that makes people either idealize or demonize everyone and everything — sometimes within the same conversation.
So let’s say someone with BPD has a joyful morning — the sun is shining, coffee tastes divine, the cat doesn’t knock anything off the counter. But then, someone forgets to text back. BAM. The world is a wasteland. Life has no meaning. That earlier joy? Fake news. Never existed. What joy?
Joy doesn’t stand a chance in a brain wired to swing between “I love you, you’re my soulmate” and “you’re dead to me” within hours. The emotional bandwidth is overloaded by survival-mode reactivity. Joy is the first casualty.
5. Invalidation Nation: When Your Joy Was Never Yours to Begin With
Let’s talk upbringing — not in a blame-the-parents way (although, yes, often it's the parents), but in a “your brain didn’t form in a vacuum” way.
Many people with BPD grew up in environments where emotions were ignored, mocked, or punished. So what happens when you experience joy in a family where emotional expression is about as welcome as a fart in church? You learn to mistrust your feelings.
Joy, like anger or sadness, becomes dangerous territory. It sets you up for disappointment, ridicule, or worse — invisibility. So even as an adult, when something joyful bubbles up, the brain says “Nope! Shut that down before you get hurt again.”
Joy becomes radioactive. Tainted. Untrustworthy. And why would anyone bask in something they’ve been taught is wrong?
6. Self-Sabotage: The Art of Kicking Your Own Joy in the Shins
You’d think when something good happens, people would lean into it. Not with BPD.
People with BPD are often masters of self-sabotage, usually without realizing it. New job? Let’s have a meltdown before the first day. Romantic spark? Better ghost them before they ghost you. Compliment from a friend? Time to overthink it until it becomes an insult.
There’s a twisted logic to this behavior: If I destroy this now, I control the pain. Joy feels vulnerable. Vulnerability feels unsafe. Control feels better than hope — especially if hope has let you down every damn time.
So yes, people with BPD can find joy… but sometimes they have to knock it over and burn it first, just to feel safe again.
7. Joy Isn’t Sustainable When Your Brain Is Playing “Survivor” 24/7
Living with BPD is like being on a permanent episode of Survivor: Emotional Island. Every social interaction is a challenge. Every slight miscommunication is a tribal council vote against your worth.
In that environment, joy becomes a luxury. A unicorn. An emotional tourist that stops by briefly but can’t afford to stay.
When your nervous system is constantly in fight-or-flight mode — hypervigilant, exhausted, analyzing everything for hidden danger — joy is not a priority. You can’t experience joy when your brain is screaming “YOU’RE NOT SAFE” every five minutes.
8. The Medication and Therapy Shuffle (Also Known As Emotional Musical Chairs)
Even when people with BPD seek help — which many do — it’s rarely a quick fix. Finding the right combo of meds, therapy, boundaries, and human decency takes years. In the meantime, joy is often the last thing on the agenda.
DBT (Dialectical Behavior Therapy) is great. So is mindfulness. And yes, medication helps. But nobody pops an SSRI and suddenly starts frolicking in meadows. Healing BPD is a long, frustrating slog. Joy might peek in occasionally, but it's often drowned out by “Why is my brain still like this?”
And let’s be honest — nothing kills a joyful buzz quite like copays, insurance denials, and therapists with six-month waiting lists.
9. The Stigma Stinks — And It Steals Joy, Too
Let’s not forget that BPD is still one of the most stigmatized mental health conditions out there. People with BPD are labeled manipulative, toxic, attention-seeking — as if their suffering is just an elaborate act in the Theater of Overreaction.
When society tells you that your pain is annoying, your joy is fake, and your very identity is a walking red flag, how the hell are you supposed to feel good about yourself?
Stigma is a joy thief. It isolates people who already feel alienated from themselves. It convinces them they’re unworthy of love, connection, or even basic happiness. And then society has the gall to ask, “Why aren’t you smiling more?”
Because, Karen. Because.
10. But Here’s the Twist: Joy Is Possible — Just Not on Your Terms
Despite all this, joy is not impossible for people with BPD. But it won’t look the way you expect.
It might be fleeting — a moment of connection, a song lyric that lands just right, a text from someone who didn’t disappear. It might be found in creating art, petting a dog, or sitting still without spiraling for 30 seconds. Small joys. Micro-joys. Surprising joys.
And yes, with time, therapy, support, and self-awareness, those small joys can stack up. They can begin to feel less suspicious and more sacred.
But here’s the deal: You don’t get to decide what joy looks like for someone else. Especially not someone whose emotional landscape has been a war zone for decades.
Final Snarky Notes
So the next time you catch yourself asking, “Why can’t people with BPD just be happy?” remember:
-
Because their brain chemistry is like a cocktail made by a bartender who hates them.
-
Because trauma doesn’t take coffee breaks.
-
Because society treats them like human hand grenades.
-
Because joy requires safety, and they’ve spent years learning the world is not safe.
Instead of asking why they can’t feel joy, try offering some — without conditions, expectations, or side-eyes. Better yet, ask how you can be a safe person in their world.
Because the truth is, they’re not broken. They’re just navigating a world that demands emotional neatness from people built with fireworks. And if you can’t handle the sparkle, you’re not invited to the damn party.