Picture this: A student named Jamie walks into the classroom on the first day of school. Jamie’s new teacher, Mrs. Thompson, has been told by the administration that Jamie scored very high on an aptitude test over the summer. What Mrs. Thompson doesn’t know is that the test results were randomly assigned—and Jamie’s real scores were average. But here's the twist: by the end of the year, Jamie is performing at the top of the class.
Coincidence? Luck? Not exactly.
Welcome to the curious world of the Pygmalion Effect—a powerful psychological phenomenon where higher expectations lead to improved performance. It's a bit like a self-fulfilling prophecy but with a motivational engine under the hood.
What Is the Pygmalion Effect?
The Pygmalion Effect, also known as the Rosenthal Effect, is a psychological concept that suggests that our expectations of others can become a reality simply because we believe in them.
Named after Pygmalion, a mythical Greek sculptor who fell in love with a statue he had carved, the concept took on psychological relevance thanks to Robert Rosenthal and Lenore Jacobson in the 1960s. Their famous experiment showed that when teachers were led to believe certain students had higher potential (regardless of the truth), those students ended up performing better academically.
That’s right. Belief alone was enough to improve academic outcomes. That’s either exhilarating or terrifying, depending on how people view you.
The Original Experiment: Rosenthal and Jacobson (1968)
Let’s rewind to the late 1960s, in a low-income elementary school in San Francisco. Psychologist Robert Rosenthal and school principal Lenore Jacobson told teachers that certain students—randomly selected, mind you—had shown exceptional potential on a Harvard-developed test (which was entirely made up for the study).
Over the course of the year, those "gifted" students (again, totally chosen at random) showed significantly higher gains in IQ compared to their classmates. Why? Because the teachers treated them differently. They expected more, gave more time and attention, and believed in their success.
It’s science. But it’s also kind of magic.
Four Mechanisms Behind the Pygmalion Effect
Rosenthal identified four key behaviors that transmit high expectations from one person to another. Whether you're a teacher, boss, coach, or even a parent, these are the subconscious levers you're probably pulling every day:
1. Climate: The Emotional Environment
We’re talking warmth here—smiles, eye contact, tone of voice. People who are expected to succeed receive warmer emotional signals, creating a more positive and supportive environment. They feel encouraged, seen, and welcomed.
Think about it: If your boss speaks to you like you're a superstar, don’t you start feeling like one?
2. Input: Quality and Quantity of Instruction
Teachers give more information and materials to students they think are brighter. Leaders spend more time with employees they believe are top-tier. It’s an investment mindset—pour more in because you expect a return.
This explains why Jamie (our random test case from earlier) got more challenging problems, more feedback, and more attention.
3. Output: Opportunities to Demonstrate Learning
High-expectation individuals get more chances to speak, solve, lead, or present. When the spotlight shines on you more often, you get more comfortable under it. People thrive when they're encouraged to perform—and when their voice is heard.
4. Feedback: Quality of Responses
When people expect you to do well, they give more nuanced, constructive, and supportive feedback. Instead of dismissing a mistake as "typical," they treat it as an anomaly—something fixable. That shift alone changes everything.
Self-Fulfilling Prophecy Meets Social Dynamics
The Pygmalion Effect is a specific kind of self-fulfilling prophecy. But what makes it especially powerful is that it requires two people—the one setting the expectations, and the one living up (or down) to them.
It’s like a dance. If one person changes their rhythm, the other follows. And just like that, reality begins to bend.
It’s also worth noting that the opposite exists too—the Golem Effect, where low expectations result in decreased performance. Tell someone they're incapable, and they often live down to it.
That’s why your middle school gym teacher saying “You’re not athletic” stuck in your brain like a barbed wire tattoo. And why you still hesitate to play pickup basketball, even though you’re perfectly coordinated now.
The Pygmalion Effect at Work
Let’s move beyond the classroom. This effect is everywhere—corporate offices, hospitals, sports teams, military units. You name it.
Managers and Employees
Multiple studies have shown that managers who expect more from their employees get better performance. Not because they threaten or micromanage—but because they believe in their team.
They give more mentoring, more opportunities, more trust. And in return, employees respond with increased motivation, effort, and confidence. It’s like performance karma.
Sales Teams
One Harvard study found that salespeople who were told they were top performers (even if it wasn’t true) ended up outperforming others in the following quarter. Confidence, driven by others’ beliefs, boosted their results.
Startups and Venture Capital
Ever wonder why some startups raise millions on shaky ideas, while others struggle with strong products? Perception of potential plays a huge role. When investors expect success, they project that expectation back onto the founders—leading to better networking, greater access to mentorship, and a magnetic buzz that attracts talent.
Even hope can go viral.
Can You Hack It? Applying the Pygmalion Effect to Your Life
The million-dollar question: How can we leverage this phenomenon for our benefit?
Here’s a non-exhaustive starter kit:
1. Expect More from Others—Out Loud
If you're a leader of any kind, communicate high expectations. Don’t assume people “just know” you believe in them. Say it. Show it. Reinforce it.
Words like:
-
“I know you’ve got this.”
-
“I’m giving you this project because I trust your skills.”
-
“You're ready for the next level.”
These aren't just feel-good phrases—they're behavioral catalysts.
2. Surround Yourself with Believers
We all have mirrors in our lives—people who reflect back how they see us. Choose mirrors who reflect your strengths, not your insecurities. High expectations from friends, mentors, or colleagues can become rocket fuel.
If you’re constantly around people who treat you like you’re just average, chances are you’ll believe them. Trade them for people who see greatness and say, “Prove me right.”
3. Expect More from Yourself
Here’s the tricky part: The Pygmalion Effect works on yourself too. That’s called the Galatea Effect—when your own expectations about your performance shape your reality.
If you believe you’re capable, you’re more likely to act in ways that reinforce that belief. Set higher goals. Stop apologizing for ambition. Upgrade your self-talk.
"I belong here" is a better mantra than "I hope I don’t get found out."
4. Be Aware of Your Biases
High expectations are powerful, but they can also reinforce inequality if applied unfairly. Teachers, managers, or coaches may unknowingly favor those who look, sound, or behave like the “ideal” performer.
Ask yourself:
-
Am I giving equal opportunity to everyone?
-
Do I only believe in those who remind me of myself?
-
Who am I underestimating?
The Pygmalion Effect doesn’t just reveal bias—it can amplify it. Use it wisely.
Criticisms and Limitations
Of course, no psychological phenomenon is without nuance. The Pygmalion Effect doesn’t work in every context.
-
Overly high expectations can create stress, resentment, or burnout.
-
Some individuals may resist expectations they perceive as manipulative or unrealistic.
-
Cultural factors, personality traits, and existing confidence levels all influence how strongly the effect shows up.
It’s not magic. But it is momentum.
Pop Culture Pygmalion
If all this sounds familiar, maybe you’ve seen it play out in your favorite stories.
-
My Fair Lady (based on George Bernard Shaw’s Pygmalion): A Cockney flower girl is transformed into a lady by a linguistics professor who believes he can teach her refinement—based on nothing but his own hubris and expectations.
-
The Pursuit of Happyness: Will Smith’s character gets a shot at a high-paying job because someone believed in his potential despite his circumstances.
-
Good Will Hunting: A janitor with a genius IQ is pulled out of obscurity by a mentor who sees past his tough exterior.
All examples of expectation breeding excellence—or at least revealing it.
The Dark Side: The Golem Effect and Undermining Potential
If the Pygmalion Effect is the fairy godmother, the Golem Effect is the evil twin.
Low expectations, even when subtly expressed, can sink performance like an anchor:
-
A boss who micromanages because they don’t trust you.
-
A teacher who never calls on you in class.
-
A parent who always assumes you’ll screw up.
These people might think they’re being “realistic,” but they’re actually engineering your failure through doubt and neglect.
Be mindful not only of whose expectations you embrace—but whose you reject.
Closing Thoughts: Sculpting Each Other’s Futures
Pygmalion sculpted a statue so perfect he fell in love with it—and the gods, taking pity or joy (we’re never quite sure), brought it to life.
That’s the metaphor behind the effect: We sculpt each other, with every glance, compliment, critique, or opportunity. What we expect from people—whether high or low—can shape their beliefs, behaviors, and ultimately, their futures.
So next time you’re tempted to write someone off—or even yourself—ask:
What might they become… if I just believed a little more?